STUDIO ETH Zürich
Spring 2024

Folding Agrarian Edges: A Vision for DübendorfAntonia Gerogianni and Diana Zarnescu

Where the city of Dübendorf ends, the landscape rapidly shifts from multifunctional high-rise and industrial buildings and large furniture stores to a neatly manicured agricultural belt. This belt is bound by both the city edge on one side and the protected edge of the forest, a sharply defined line at the edge of the monocultural fields. The abrupt edges at the limits of Zürich result from multiscalar processes of zoning and land protection measures that aim to mediate the distribution of land between three main land-use “forces”: food production, accommodation of a rapidly growing population and nature preservation.

The acceleration of land use change and the expansion of the Zürich Urban Agglomeration has led to the shrinking of agricultural land and a structural change in the farm size; Farms in Dübendorf have decreased in number from 177 in 1954 to 22 in 2024, while the average farm size has doubled throughout Switzerland. As a regulatory mechanism, zoning has delineated clear boundaries around the agricultural fields that are currently protected in a system of crop rotation areas known as Fruchtfolgeflächen, occasionally dissected by biodiversity protection zones and public leisure areas. In a context where substantial demographic changes and extensive densification of the urban fabric are foreseen, we ask whether the agricultural belt surrounding Dübendorf can become a mediating fabric that diffuses the edges of nature protection and settlement. What mechanisms can generate programmatic flexibilities between the land uses of Dübendorf?

Positioned at the fringe of Dübendorf city, we propose to read the agricultural belt as a transition area, potentially generating a new territorial coherence. The project aims to reconstruct exchanges between agriculture and the urban, expanding into the densely urbanised area of Dübendorf city and supporting the formation of “edible” public spaces. Agriculture then unfolds in a series of practices that start from the extension of the forest edge into a layer of fodder shrubs and rotational grazing, which weaves through the agricultural fabric and pushes back the city edge.

Acknowledgements

We would like to express our heartfelt thanks to the ETH staff for their help and support throughout this project. Additionally, we send our special thanks to Flavia Sutter, Thomas Winter, and Philipp Reibisch for providing us with crucial information about the Dübendorf Nature Conservation Association, to Dirk Rahnenführer for sharing extensive information about family gardens in Dübendorf and Switzerland, to Bettina Wolfgramm for introducing us to the Huebhof Farm, to Sabina Keller for the insights shared during the earthworm workshop; and to Svenja Hirt for her assistance with information on existing projects by the BirdLife Association. Thank you for your time and your generous support.

Photographs and images by authors unless otherwise indicated.

The project texts were developed within the course „Critical Writing“, SS 2024, by Dr. Nancy Couling and Alice Clarke. The chapters above have been edited for consistency and accuracy by the MAS editorial team: Nancy Couling, Alice Clarke and Erzë Dinarama.

Sources

  • Beck, Travis, ed. 2013. Principles of Ecological Landscape Design. Landscape Architecture, Ecology. Washington Covelo London: Island Press.
  • Dubendorf City. 2018. ‘Networking Project According to DZV -3rd Stage 2018 to 2025’.
  • Ernst Basler + Partner AG. 2006. ‘Landschaftsentwicklungskonzept (LEK) Dubendorf’.
  • Federal Statistical Office FSO and Federal Department of Home Affairs FDHA. 2018. ‘Land Use in Switzerland Results of the Swiss Land Use Statistics 2018’. 02. Territory and Environment. Neuchatel, Switzerland.
  • Florentina Gartmann and Frank Auderset. 2022. Der Greifensee. Symbiose von Naherholung Und Naturschutz? Neujahrsblatt der Naturforschenden Gesellschaft in Zürich NGZH.
  • FOEN. 2010. ‘Gefährdete Arten in der Schweiz’.
  • George McKay. 2011. Radical Gardening: Politics, Idealism and Rebellion in the Garden. Frances Lincoln.
  • Grouppe Krokodil. 2008. Glatt! Manifest Fur Eine Stadt Im Werden. Edited by Roger Boltshauser, Sascha Roesler, and Fabian Hörmann, Mathias Müller, Daniel Niggli, Frank Zierau, Raphael Frei, Andreas Sonderegger, Mischa Spoerri, Lukas Schweingruber. Park Books.
  • Haeg Fritz. 2008. Edible Estates: Attack on the Front Lawn. Distributed Art Publishers.
  • Harvey, Mark. 2014. ‘The Food-Energy-Climate Change Trilemma: Toward a Socio-Economic Analysis’. Theory, Culture & Society 31 (5): 155–82. https://doi.org/10\.1177/0263276414537317\.
  • Ineichen, Stefan, Ruckstuhl, Max, and Hose, Stefan. 2022. Neue Stadtfauna 700 Tierarten Der Stadt Zürich. Haupt Verlag.
  • IPBES. 2019. ‘The Global Assessment Report on BIODIVERSITY AND ECOSYSTEM SERVICES’.
  • IUCN, WCPA - World COmminission on protected Areas, WCS, and National Geographic. n.d. ‘CONSERVING AT LEAST 30% OF THE PLANET BY 2030, What Should Count?’
  • Jacobs, Jane(Author). 1916. Death and Life of Great American Cities. Vintage Books ed.
  • Joel Garreau. 1991. Edge City: Life on the New Frontier. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group.
  • Mario Campi, Franz Bucher, and Mirko Zardini. 2001. The Almost Perfect Periphery: Glattalstadt/Greater Zurich Area. Basel: Birkhauser - Verlag fur Architektur.
  • ———. n.d.-b. ‘Konzept Arten- und Lebensraumförderung’.
  • Pfiffner, Lukas, Sibylle Stöckli, and FiBL Switzerland. 2023. ‘Agriculture and Biodiversity’. Agriculture and Biodiversity.
  • Richard Reynolds. 2009. Guerilla Gardening - A Botanical Manifesto. Orange-Press GmbH.
  • Richard T. Forman, Wenche E. Dramstad, and James D. Olson. 1996. ‘Landscape Ecology Principles in Landscape Architecture and Land-Use Planning’. Island Press.
  • SCNAT and Swiss Academy of Science - Factsheets. 2020. ‘Biodiversity Damaging Subsidies in Switzerland’. 7.
  • Stavrides Stavros. 2024. ‘Urban Porosity and the Right to a Shared City’. In Porous City: From Metaphor to Urban Agenda, edited by Sophie Wolfrum, 32–37. Berlin, Boston: Birkhäuse.
  • Stavros, Stavrides. 2019. Towards the City of Thresholds. Common Notions.
  • The Federal Assembly of the Swiss Confederation. 2022. ‘Federal Act on the Protection of Nature and Cultural Heritage (NCHA)’.
  • Tilman, David, Robert Socolow, Jonathan A. Foley, Jason Hill, Eric Larson, Lee Lynd, Stephen Pacala, et al. 2009. ‘Beneficial Biofuels—The Food, Energy, and Environment Trilemma’. Science 325 (5938): 270–71. https://doi.org/10\.1126/science.1177970\.
  • Tschander, Bettina. n.d.-a. ‘Concept of Species and Habitat Promotion’.
  • UN Convention on Biological Diversity. 2022. ‘Report of the Open-Ended Working Group on the Post-2020 Global Biodiversity Framework on Its Third Meeting (Part II)’, March.
  • Wälty, Sibylle. 2022. ‘How to Achieve Parsimonious Urban Land Use: The Case of Greater Zurich’. European Planning Studies 30 (2): 292–310. https://doi.org/10\.1080/09654313\.2021\.1948973\.
  • WWF. 2022. ‘Living Planet Report 2022 - Building a Nature-Positive Society’. Gland, Switzerland.
  • Zurcher Plannungruppe Glattal ZPG. 2009. ‘Von Der Agglomeration Zur City - Fakten, Zahnlen, Erinnerungen Und Ausblick’.

ETH Zürich D-ARCH

Programme Director
Milica Topalović, Assoc. Professor
Chair of Architecture and Territorial Planinng

Programme Co-ordinator
Dr. Nancy Couling

EPFL ENAC

Programme Director
Paola Viganò, Professor
Habitat Research Center

Programme Co-ordinator
Dr. Tommaso Pietropolli